$0 OWCP and OPM Annuity Comparison Worksheet

OWCP Wage-Loss Compensation vs OPM Disability Retirement: Choosing the Right Benefit Stream

If you are a federal or postal employee weighing FECA wage-loss compensation against an OPM disability retirement annuity, the short answer is that OWCP almost always pays more in take-home cash — but the OPM annuity carries protections that OWCP does not. The right choice depends on your age, dependent status, tax bracket, medical prognosis, and how long you expect to need benefits. This page lays out the structural differences so you can compare them against your own numbers.

How the Two Programmes Work

OWCP pays wage-loss compensation under the Federal Employees' Compensation Act (5 U.S.C. 8101 et seq.) for injuries sustained in the performance of duty. OPM pays a disability retirement annuity under FERS (5 U.S.C. 8452) or CSRS (5 U.S.C. 8337) for any medical condition — work-related or not — that prevents useful and efficient service. The dual-benefit bar at 5 U.S.C. 8116(a) prohibits receiving both simultaneously, so you must elect one through Form CA-1105.

The election is revocable. You can switch later if circumstances change.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Factor OWCP Wage-Loss Compensation OPM Disability Retirement (FERS)
Payment rate 66⅔% of pay rate (no dependents) or 75% (with dependents) If under 62 and not eligible for immediate voluntary retirement: 60% of High-3 for the first 12 months, then 40%; reduced by 100% of Social Security benefits in the first 12 months and 60% of Social Security disability benefits afterward; earned annuity applies if higher
Federal income tax Generally exempt; FECA amounts that reduce Social Security benefits may be taxable as Social Security income Generally taxable, except for tax-free recovery of employee contributions
Cost-of-living adjustments Annual FECA COLA on March 1 when disability began more than one year earlier FERS COLA rules apply (generally CPI-based, with limits)
Medical coverage for accepted injury OWCP pays all reasonable treatment under 5 U.S.C. 8103 OWCP still covers the accepted condition, regardless of election
Health insurance (FEHB/PSHB) Premiums deducted from compensation after transfer Premiums deducted from annuity
Life insurance (FEGLI) Continues if enrolled; premiums deducted Continues if 5-year rule met; post-65 reduction depends on the election
Service credit Up to 6 months of nonpay status per calendar year is creditable for retirement; excess is not Disability time credited at age-62 recomputation
TSP contributions Cannot contribute from FECA payments Cannot contribute (no salary)
Outside earnings Wage-earning capacity determination under 5 U.S.C. 8115 For annuitants under age 60, wages and self-employment income at 80% of current basic pay for the former position in any calendar year trigger termination of the annuity effective June 30 of the following year
Annual reporting Form EN-1032 (sent with Form CA-1032 cover letter) OPM Disability Earnings Survey (until age 60)
Duration Continues while disability and entitlement persist Recomputed at age 62; converts to regular annuity

Who OWCP Typically Favours

OWCP compensation tends to deliver higher net income for employees with dependents (the 75% rate on a generally tax-exempt payment often exceeds double the after-tax OPM annuity), employees far from age 62 (more years at the higher FECA rate), and employees whose accepted condition is well-documented and unlikely to trigger a wage-earning capacity determination.

Free Download

Get the OWCP and OPM Annuity Comparison Worksheet

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

Who OPM Disability Retirement Typically Favours

The OPM annuity provides stronger long-term stability for employees approaching age 62 (the age-62 recomputation adds projected service and COLAs), employees whose OWCP claim is under review or at risk of termination after a suitable-work determination, and employees who want the security of a lifetime annuity that does not depend on continued OWCP acceptance.

Who This Is For

  • Federal or postal employees who received Form CA-1105 and need to understand both options before responding
  • Employees with an accepted OWCP claim who have been told they could also file for disability retirement
  • Family members helping an injured worker evaluate the two programmes
  • Separated employees on OWCP who need to decide whether to activate a suspended OPM annuity

Who This Is NOT For

  • Employees with no accepted OWCP claim (the election only applies when both benefits are available)
  • Employees seeking investment advice on TSP withdrawals or annuity-supplement strategies
  • Employees looking for help filing the initial OWCP claim or the initial OPM disability application

The Factor Most People Overlook

The one-year post-separation deadline under 5 U.S.C. 8453 runs regardless of OWCP status. If your agency separated you and you have not filed for OPM disability retirement, that deadline is ticking. You can file for OPM to protect the deadline without electing OPM over OWCP — the annuity goes into suspended status while you continue on FECA. Missing the one-year window bars the application unless OPM grants the statutory waiver for mental incompetence at separation or within one year afterward; the application must then be filed within one year after restoration to competency or appointment of a fiduciary, whichever is earlier. No amount of OWCP wage-loss compensation can restore the deadline.

Tradeoffs Worth Weighing

OWCP's advantage is cash flow. A GS-12 employee earning $7,000 a month with dependents receives $5,250 monthly from OWCP, generally tax-free. The same employee's FERS disability annuity would be $2,800 gross in year two, generally taxable except for tax-free recovery of employee contributions, and reduced further by SSDI.

OPM's advantage is permanence. An OPM annuity is not subject to the same medical review or suitable-work determination that can reduce or terminate OWCP. And at age 62, the FERS disability annuity is recomputed as though you had worked continuously, with COLAs added to your High-3.

Medical coverage stays either way. Electing OPM does not close your OWCP claim. OWCP remains responsible for medical treatment of the accepted condition under 5 U.S.C. 8103, regardless of which payment stream you choose.

You can switch. The election is revocable. If OWCP terminates your wage loss after a suitable-work determination, you can activate the suspended OPM annuity. If you are on OPM and your medical condition worsens, you can contact OWCP about returning to compensation.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I receive both OWCP wage-loss compensation and an OPM annuity at the same time?

No. The dual-benefit bar at 5 U.S.C. 8116(a) prohibits concurrent receipt of FECA wage-loss compensation and an OPM retirement or disability annuity. You must elect one. The exception is FECA schedule awards for permanent impairment under 5 U.S.C. 8107, which can be received alongside an OPM annuity.

Is the OWCP/OPM election permanent?

No. Under 20 CFR 10.421(a), the election between wage-loss compensation and a retirement annuity is revocable. You can change your election when your circumstances change.

Does electing OPM close my OWCP claim?

No. Electing OPM suspends FECA wage-loss payments but leaves your OWCP medical entitlement fully active. OWCP continues to cover all reasonable medical treatment for the accepted condition.

What happens to my health insurance during the switch?

FEHB or PSHB enrolment transfers from OWCP to OPM; OWCP and OPM coordinate the transfer promptly to avoid a coverage lapse. If OWCP compensation continues beyond the first 365 days in leave without pay status, OPM applies the five-year rule (or first-opportunity alternative) for continued health enrollment as of the date you started receiving compensation. Premiums switch from OWCP's 28-day deduction to OPM's monthly deduction.

How do I compare the actual numbers for my situation?

The OPM Disability Retirement or OWCP Workers' Compensation: The Federal Employee's Election Guide includes a financial comparison worksheet where you enter your pay rate, High-3, dependency status, estimated taxes, and SSDI offset to calculate your net monthly income under each programme.

Do I need an attorney for this?

For the administrative task of understanding the election and completing Form CA-1105, many employees handle it themselves with structured guidance. If you are contesting an overpayment at ECAB or appealing a denial at MSPB, an attorney familiar with federal benefits law may be warranted.

Get Your Free OWCP and OPM Annuity Comparison Worksheet

Download the OWCP and OPM Annuity Comparison Worksheet — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →