$0 OWCP and OPM Annuity Comparison Worksheet

OWCP vs. OPM Retirement Comparison Worksheet: How to Calculate Your Net Benefit

Why a Side-by-Side Comparison Matters

Form CA-1102 shows the gross FECA rate, but it doesn't tell you what you'll actually take home. FECA compensation is tax-free. An OPM disability annuity is taxable income. OPM offsets SSDI against a FERS disability annuity, while SSA may separately reduce SSDI when it is paid with workers' compensation. Health insurance premiums come out of both, but through different payment cycles. Without running the net math yourself, the two options aren't really comparable.

The framework below walks through the inputs you need to gather and the calculations to run. It is not financial advice and does not tell you which option to choose — it gives you the same numbers a benefits counselor would put together, so you can make an informed decision.

Step 1: Gather Your Baseline Numbers

You need five pieces of data:

  • Your pay rate for OWCP — generally the rate at injury, when disability began, or at a qualifying recurrence, using the greatest applicable rate under 5 U.S.C. 8101(4). A recurrence-rate rule applies when recurrence begins more than six months after return to regular full-time federal work
  • Your high-3 average salary — this is the base for OPM. Your agency HR office can provide it; pay records and SF-50s can help verify the salary history
  • Your dependency status — at least one qualifying dependent bumps FECA from 66⅔% to 75%
  • Your SSDI monthly award (if receiving or eligible) — OPM will offset this against the disability annuity
  • Your FEHB/PSHB premium — use the amount for your actual enrollment; the deduction frequency differs under OWCP and OPM

Step 2: Calculate OWCP Net

FECA total-disability compensation is straightforward:

  • Without dependents: 66⅔% of your pay rate
  • With dependents: 75% of your pay rate

The result is excluded from income under 26 U.S.C. 104(a)(1). No federal income tax or FICA applies to FECA compensation for personal injury or sickness. Your net OWCP benefit equals the gross minus your health insurance premium (deducted from the 28-day check) and any FEGLI premium.

Free Download

Get the OWCP and OPM Annuity Comparison Worksheet

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

Step 3: Calculate OPM Disability Net

This is where it gets more complex:

Year 1 (under age 62, not eligible for immediate voluntary retirement): 60% of high-3, minus 100% of any SSDI benefit to which you are entitled.

Year 2+ (until age 62): 40% of high-3, minus 60% of any SSDI benefit to which you are entitled.

Earned-annuity floor: If your actual accrued service produces a higher annuity under the standard FERS formula, you get that amount instead.

Then subtract estimated federal income tax (the annuity is taxable income), applicable state income tax, and your health insurance premium (deducted monthly by OPM).

Step 4: Compare the Results

Place both net figures side by side. For most federal employees with dependents, OWCP's 75% tax-free rate produces significantly more monthly cash than the FERS disability annuity after tax and SSDI offsets. A GS-12 with an $84,000 OWCP pay rate, a high-3 of $84,000, and one dependent might see roughly $5,250/month in gross OWCP compensation before insurance premiums versus around $2,000/month net from FERS disability in year two (after SSDI offset and taxes).

But the comparison doesn't end at monthly cash. Consider:

  • Duration: OWCP compensation continues as long as the medical condition and wage-loss entitlement persist, but can be reduced or terminated through vocational rehabilitation determinations. OPM disability retirement is more stable once approved.
  • Outside earnings: OWCP monitors wage-earning capacity under 5 U.S.C. 8115. OPM terminates the disability annuity if earnings equal at least 80% of your former position's current pay rate.
  • TSP access: TSP contributions are based on basic pay and stop during LWOP. After separation, withdrawal eligibility follows TSP separation rules, not whether you elect OWCP or OPM.
  • Insurance continuity: Both options can maintain FEHB/PSHB and FEGLI, but the transfer mechanics differ.

The Guide's Full Worksheet

The OWCP vs. OPM Election Guide includes a printable financial comparison worksheet with blank input fields for each of these calculations, plus rows for COLAs, the age-62 recomputation, and schedule-award concurrent-receipt projections. It's designed so a family helper can fill it in alongside the injured employee and bring it to a benefits counselor or financial adviser.

Get Your Free OWCP and OPM Annuity Comparison Worksheet

Download the OWCP and OPM Annuity Comparison Worksheet — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →