$0 OWCP and OPM Annuity Comparison Worksheet

OWCP Retirement Election Checklist: Certified Mail, Audit Logs, and Tracking Correspondence

Why Documentation Matters More Than Anything Else

The OWCP-OPM election involves two federal agencies that don't share systems. When things go wrong — an overpayment notice, a delayed annuity, an insurance premium lapse — the first question is always "when did you send it, and can you prove they received it?"

Every ECAB case involving a disputed overpayment turns on the paper trail. Employees who can produce certified-mail receipts, dated copies of every form, and a log of phone calls with representative names are in a dramatically stronger position than those who relied on verbal assurances.

Pre-Election Checklist

Before submitting Form CA-1105, verify each of these:

OPM disability application filed. If you haven't already filed SF 3107 and SF 3112 (A through E), do it now. The one-year post-separation deadline under 5 U.S.C. 8453 does not wait for OWCP. Confirm receipt with OPM in writing.

OPM approval status confirmed. Contact OPM Retirement Services to verify whether your disability application has been approved, denied, or is still pending. If approved, confirm the annuity is in suspended status. Get this in writing.

CA-1102 reviewed. Read OWCP's election information carefully. Verify the pay rate, dependency status, and gross FECA compensation figures. Confirm your OPM annuity estimate separately with OPM, and resolve any discrepancy before electing.

Net comparison completed. Run the after-tax, after-SSDI, after-premium comparison yourself. CA-1102 shows the gross FECA rate; your decision should be based on net take-home.

Health insurance continuity verified. Confirm your FEHB or PSHB enrollment meets the five-year rule. Check whether your enrollment will transfer smoothly from OWCP to OPM or whether you need to arrange direct premium payments during the transition.

FEGLI status confirmed. Verify your life insurance coverage and whether you need to file SF 2818 to continue coverage and make the post-65 reduction election.

Sending CA-1105

Send the completed Form CA-1105 to your OWCP District Office by USPS Certified Mail with Return Receipt Requested. Keep:

  • A photocopy of the completed form (front and back)
  • The certified mail receipt with tracking number
  • The green return receipt card when it comes back (or the electronic delivery confirmation)

Note the date you mailed it and the date OWCP received it. These dates matter if there's ever a dispute about when the election took effect or whether OWCP processed it on time.

Free Download

Get the OWCP and OPM Annuity Comparison Worksheet

Everything in this article as a printable checklist — plus action plans and reference guides you can start using today.

Building an Audit Log

Start a simple tracking sheet from the moment you receive CA-1102 and CA-1105. For every interaction with OWCP, OPM, your agency HR, SSA, or your FEHB/PSHB carrier, record:

  • Date of the contact
  • Agency and office (e.g., OWCP/DFEC, Denver; OPM Retirement Services)
  • Person's name and title (or reference number for online submissions)
  • Method (phone, certified mail, ECOMP, email)
  • Summary of what was discussed or submitted
  • Tracking/confirmation number if applicable

This log serves double duty. It helps you keep track of a complex multi-agency process, and it creates the evidentiary record you'd need to support a "without fault" argument if an overpayment is ever declared.

Post-Election Follow-Up

After submitting CA-1105, don't assume everything will process automatically:

  • Confirm OWCP received and processed the election (call and document the conversation)
  • Verify the date OWCP stopped wage-loss payments
  • Confirm OPM received OWCP's notification and activated (or is processing) your annuity
  • Watch for the first OPM payment — if interim pay doesn't arrive within a reasonable timeframe, follow up in writing
  • Monitor health insurance premium deductions during the transition

The OWCP vs. OPM Election Guide includes printable versions of this checklist plus a structured correspondence log template with columns for every field above — designed to be filled in by the injured employee or a family helper and kept as a permanent record.

Get Your Free OWCP and OPM Annuity Comparison Worksheet

Download the OWCP and OPM Annuity Comparison Worksheet — a printable guide with checklists, scripts, and action plans you can start using today.

Learn More →